Last updated on October 25th, 2020

These thick gluten-free pumpkin pancakes are soft and fluffy and loaded with holiday pumpkin spice! They’re the perfect quick breakfast to make with kids on fall mornings or serve up for your holiday brunch with a drizzle of maple syrup.

If you would have asked me 6 months ago for a gluten-free pancake recipe, I’d tell you to make waffles instead. But you’re not a cheery 2.5 year old with a Curious George Makes Pancakes obsession who has me wrapped around her finger. When Zoella woke up one Sunday morning begging to make the pancake recipe printed in the back of her Curious George book, I couldn’t say no. I could, however, suggest we make our own gluten-free recipe and that’s just what we did. Together, we threw things into a mixing bowl (and on the floor) and hoped it’d cook up into golden brown flapjacks. She added sprinkles, of course.

To my groggy surprise, they turned out pretty dang delicious. That’s the very moment I had a change of heart about pancakes. When made with flavorful whole grain flours and fried up with crispy edges and a soft fluffy center, they’re on par with waffles. For months, I’ve tweaked and jotted down recipe notes every time she asks for pancakes, eventually writing a gluten-free pumpkin recipe variation to try next. 

Then one Sunday morning last month, Lucas gave me a little extra sleep-in time by waking up early with the kids (my hero). Not wanting to disturb me, but needing guidance, he tip-toed in with “pancakes.docx” open on my laptop. “Is this the pancake recipe?” he whispered, pointing to the pumpkin version. Let’s recap: my husband was awake with a toddler and a baby. MAKING PANCAKES. While I slept.

I confirmed and he went back to the kitchen. My notes listed ingredients but no steps, so sure enough, he came back a few minutes later. I advised him to mix the dry, then separate the egg — and that’s when he stopped me, wide-eyed, “We’ll wait until you get up for that step.” Ha!

Though honestly, if the whole family is up making pancakes, I definitely want in on that memory making. So up I got.

And that’s the origin of these gluten-free pumpkin pancakes, first tested by my toddler and husband.

How to make gluten-free pancakes

As far as gluten-free flour-based recipes go, pancakes and waffles are probably the hardest to mess up. We’re after the best gluten-free pancakes, though. The thick lofty kind that have golden crispy edges and moist, soft centers. The kind that are so flavorful that you hardly even need maple syrup (except what’s a pancake without?). These oat flour pancakes are just that. 

Oat flour works to soak up the pumpkin, creating a soft center and adding sweet whole grain notes. Sweet rice flour acts as the binder to give the slight chewiness, while tapioca starch similarly binds while also helping the edges crisp up.

Fat from real deal buttermilk and plenty of butter make for a rich and flavorful batter. Texturally, the buttermilk helps create lofty thick pancakes. Butter seeps out to help fry and crisp up the edges. Pumpkin and plenty of spices turn these buttermilk pumpkin pancakes into the perfect fall or holiday brunch pancake. 

When I make waffles, I separate and whip the egg whites, which is what I did in many early iterations of these pancakes. Until my friend Erica posted this epic best pancake comparison and noted that she discovered that whipping the egg white didn’t change the pancake much if at all, but the key was just to keep the egg white separate and mix it in last. So that’s what I do now and she’s right!

Can you substitute buttermilk?

When I find myself with half a quart of buttermilk, I add pancakes to the weekend plans. But what if it’s Sunday morning and you have a hankering for gluten-free pumpkin pancakes and no buttermilk? This is the more common scenario – I rarely keep buttermilk on hand. Don’t fear – you can still have pancakes!

My solution is to make “homemade” buttermilk with pantry staples. Mix scant 1 cup whole milk with 1 tablespoon white vinegar and letting it sit for 5 minutes. That’s it! While buttermilk gives a little more loft and richness, unless you’re eating them side by side, it’s hard to tell the difference compared to the faux buttermilk pancake.

How to make uniformly-sized pancakes

If you want perfectly round uniformly-sized pancakes, I recommend using trigger ice cream scoop. Most are exactly 1/4 cup and the trigger will push out all the batter in perfectly round circles! If you’ve got a toddler, use a small cookie scoop to add Mikey Mouse ear-sized circles.

Use up extra oat flour, sweet rice flour, or tapioca starch

All three of these flours are used frequently in my gluten-free baking so I consider them pantry staples. If you’re new to gluten-free flours, it can be intimidating to buy three different flours if you aren’t sure you’ll use them all! Here are a few recipes that use all three or you can view a visual grid of all the recipes on my site that use all three of these flours in my recipe filter. 

• Chicken pot pie with chestnut biscuits
• Vanilla bean pear persimmon pie
• Ginger goat cheese cheesecake with honey roasted figs and hazelnuts

Perfect gluten-free pumpkin pancakes

Filled with a familiar Fall blend of spices – cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves (alternatively: pumpkin spice) – these pancakes are comforting and nostalgic. The pumpkin is subtle against its spice companion, but adds depth and moisture. They’re lofty but soft and moist. Not too cakey. Equipped with a crisp buttery armor. 

When pancakes are this rich and flavorful, a simple pat of butter and drizzle of maple syrup are all you need. Toss on some toasted pecans for garnish if you’re feeling festive!