Snixy Kitchen

A Bay Area gluten-free food blog with original seasonal recipes

Pepperoni pizza quesadillas

by

Last updated on April 8th, 2019

Pepperoni Pizza Quesadillas

I’ve been holding out on you. While I have been able to squeeze in a bit of time in the kitchen, finding time to write about it is a totally different story. We got home from Whistler/Vancouver/Seattle Wednesday morning around 2:30am, only to wake up a few hours later to a jam-packed workday. The evening ended with a food-filled celebration for Chuy’s birthday complete with pepperoni pizza quesadillas and gooey strawberry chocolate chip brownies prepared by yours truly.

Thursday was occupied by errands, unpacking, laundry, and re-packing, while simultaneously tending to my grad school duties before leaving for the airport at 4:30am this morning. Up in the air, again. Luckily, eating hasn’t fallen by the wayside amidst all this globetrotting.

Seattle Public Market
To honor Facebook’s billion dollar purchase, we captured our stops via Instagram.

While visiting someplace new, I most look forward to dining at the local eateries. So, to keep you on the edge of your seat for these addicting birthday quesadillas, I’ll update you on my travels by sharing my edible experiences. With restaurant week in full swing, we couldn’t have timed our arrival to Seattle any more perfectly. My pal Alicia made reservations at one of Tom Douglas’s restaurants, Dahlia Lounge, and the food was so divine that it made me forget I’d been up since 4am with only 3 hours of sleep behind me. You can’t beat a fancy three-course meal that includes leek and salsa verde soup and a leg of lamb for only $15.

Whistler

A breathtakingly scenic five-hour car ride later we arrived in Whistler only to discover that Canada + Ski Resort = pricey restaurants. Too cheap to buy a proper lunch, I survived Sunday on beef jerky and Coca Cola samples from the Telus festival happening in the village (good timing at work again?). On our last night there, I indecisively ordered two “appetizer portions” of grilled shrimp and mussels that arrived on two entrée-sized plates. And we thought Americans ate too much. Since we were paying an arm and a leg for it, I had to eat all 12 shrimp and 20 mussels – no seafood left behind!

Vancouver

While Lucas and my parents gallivanted around town, the extent of my tourism in Vancouver included hefty meals between conference sessions. With plenty of recommendations from friends, we maximized every food hour. We hit up Diners, Drive-ins, and Dives’s Fresh. Local. Wild. for seafood poutine and fried oysters, scarfed down pulled noodles and pan-fried dumplings at a Chinese noodle house, and nibbled from a tasting menu with large servings of meats and cheeses. All this in less than 24 hours. I’ve eaten enough to hibernate for a few months, but instead, I plan to eat twice as much in Philly.

Pepperoni Pizza Quesadillas

With only one free night to cook between trips, these pepperoni pizza quesadillas were a stroke of genius. Only 48 hours at home meant very little time for cooking, but I couldn’t very well let Chuy starve for his birthday – what kind of friend would I be?! Baking subtracted even more from the dinner preparation time, but what’s a birthday without dessert?

Pepperoni Pizza Quesadillas with dipping sauce

Quesadillas are about the quickest thing you can make, so they’re one of my go-to quick dinner options. Whether I’m throwing pulled pork in Texas BBQ pulled pork quesadillas or marinating beef for Korean beef quesadillas, they’re always a cheesy hit.

These cheesy tortillas tasted exactly like fresh oven-baked pizza, but required less than 10 minutes to make. Plus, they were way more fun because we got to dip them in the pizza sauce. The key ingredient to making them so mouth-watering was pan-fried high-quality pepperoni to give each bite the crispy texture reminiscent of real pizza. It was a high flavor payoff for a meal that took only a couple of minutes, and Chuy was a happy camper.

Thanks for reading Snixy Kitchen! To stay up on what’s coming out of my kitchen, follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Bloglovin’, or Pinterest, or subscribe via e-mail to get new recipes right to your inbox.

Pepperoni pizza quesadillas

Pepperoni pizza quesadillas

Yield: 4 quesadillas

Ingredients

  • 8 flour tortillas (I used Trader Joe’s handmade tortillas)
  • 8 ounces of shredded mozzarella cheese
  • 1/3 lb pepperoni
  • 1 16-ounce jar of pizza sauce
  • Optional: 1 6-ounce can of sliced black olives, 1 cup of sliced cremini mushrooms

Instructions

  1. Heat a medium skillet over medium heat and fry the pepperoni until crisp. Transfer on a paper towel to drain.
  2. Brush each tortilla with a thin layer of pizza sauce (so thin that if you turned it over, none would drip).
  3. Sprinkle cheese on top of the sauce on the bottom tortilla. Top with pepperoni and other toppings, if desired. Sprinkle with another layer of cheese and place the other tortilla on top (sauce side in).
  4. Pre-heat a medium cast-iron skilled over medium heat.
  5. Lay quesadilla in the pan and cook for 3-5 minutes on each side, until cheese is melted and tortillas are crispy.
  6. Slice into quarters and serve with a little bowl of pizza dipping sauce.
© Sarah Menanix

Snixy Kitchen

SUBSCRIBE NOW

get free recipes straight to your inbox:

Reader Interactions

You may also enjoy:

The Best Gluten-Free Pizza Crust Recipe
Gluten-Free Pizza Crust, Brazilian Cheese Bread Style
Cauliflower Macaroni and Cheese
Baked gluten-free mac and cheese with cauliflower
Hash Brown Breakfast Pizza with Asparagus
Hash Brown Breakfast Pizza with Asparagus
Cheesy Cauliflower and Kale Baked Rigatoni
Cheesy Cauliflower & Kale Baked Rigatoni with Sage Breadcrumbs

167 Comments

  6. Deanna -

    We’ve been making these for a long time and love them – we call them ‘pizzadillas’ our kids love them too – we also make what we call ‘rancheros’ which is just a quesadilla with cheese and ranch and maybe ham or chicken if we have it.

    Reply

  9. Rachel Diaz -

    My 4 year old daughter just saw the picture and said “that looks yummy!” Can’t wait to try it tomorrow night for dinner. Thank you for the idea.

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      That’s a GOOD question – it’s actually one of my biggest gripes with the standard themes on wordpress. Unfortunately, I can’t control the themes, but we’re currently building a custom theme that will be launched VERY soon and this is one of the options I’ve made available. Until then, I’ll e-mail you a printable version of the recipe. Thanks for the feedback:)

      Reply

      • Darlene Wagner -

        I’m new to pinterest and just saw this recipe. Could you e-mail me the printable recipe also. Thanks!

        Reply

        • Sarah Menanix -

          A PDF version should be in your e-mail inbox now! Also, just for your reference – if you’d like to print any other recipes, I’ve now added that feature to the site – Just click the little button on the bottom right of the recipe that says “Print This!” Let me know if it’s not working and I’ll look into it! Thanks for stopping by – hope you enjoy the quesadillas:)

          Reply

  11. Sherri L. W. -

    What do you mean by “pan fried high quality” pepperoni? Did You pan fry it first or is that how you buy it?

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      Good question! Sorry for the confusion – I bought high quality pepperoni from the butcher and pan fried it before putting it in the quesadillas. Updated the recipe to be more clear – thanks!

      Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      The nutritional information will really change a lot depending on the type of tortilla you use, whether you add pepperoni, etc. If you know what specific ingredients you’ll use, you can calculate the exact information on a site like http://recipes.sparkpeople.com/recipe-calculator.asp. However, with my ingredients these delicious quesadillas weigh in at about 500-600 calories – certainly not something you’ll want to eat for every meal, but a perfect indulgence every once in awhile!

      Reply

  13. scrappinobsessionsusan -

    seems like I can omit the frying of the pepperoni? I have never done that, and just put it in the tortilla … what do you think?

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      Technically, pepperoni doesn’t need to be cooked before eating, so it’ll be just fine for you to put it in without frying it. However, since the quesadilla takes barely any time to cook, the pepperoni will only be heated at best, leaving them soggier than they would be on an oven-baked pizza. So, it’s up to your personal preference, but I highly recommend tossing it around in a pan for a couple minutes beforehand (just like you do with bacon). Let me know what you end up doing and how it turns out!

      Reply

  14. Sheila B -

    My family ( except ) my husband love pizza. This way everyone can make their own the they like it and I don’t have to order pizza from 2 different pizza places. My youngest son and I like banana peppers, bacon, and extra cheese on our pizza. So he and I will try this and see how it turns out. Thanks for another quick and fun idea for dinner or anytime.

    Reply

  17. Michele Blackhurst -

    We made these for supper tonight and they were a hit! Even with my picky eaters! Thanks for the quick and easy meal idea! :)

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      I have not, but I’m not a huge fan of corn tortillas. If you like corn tortillas, I bet they’d be good (although the tortillas might add an extra layer of flavor where the flour tortillas sort of blend into the background). There are also other GF options like these tortillas that might be more comparable to flour tortillas: http://www.latortillafactory.com/products-6.aspx. I’ll keep my eye out next time I’m at the store to see if they sell them at the larger supermarkets!

      Reply

    • Laurie -

      Sarah, we make quesadillas all the time with corn taco shells or gluten free ones. Our favorite gluten free tortilla is made by Rudis. It is pretty expensive but we love that they don’t crack like most other gluten free brands. For a cheaper version we use Brown Rice tortillas by Food for Life.
      Our favorite fixings are: #1 cooked salmon, cheese, basil and sour cream or pesto, #2 chicken, cheese and a garlic seasoning.
      This is my teenage boys go to food when they are in a hurry.

      Reply

      • Laurie -

        I forgot to add…we put a thin layer of butter on the tortilla and put the butter side down in the pan (non stick). It makes for a crispy outside. :-)

        Reply

        • Sarah Menanix -

          Thanks for the recommendations! Now that I’m eating gluten-free, I’ve actually have started using some of the brown rice tortillas from Trader Joe’s. I was also just planning to make some quesadillas using corn tortillas this weekend. I’ve finally found some corn tortillas brands that I really do like (some of the major cheapo brands just don’t cut it!) I’ll have to look for the Rudi’s brand – I haven’t come across those yet. Thanks again for the ideas:)

          Reply

  22. Laura H -

    These are great!!! Quick, easy and delicious!!!! I love how everyone can personalize it!! Kids had pepperoni and cheese, while I added mushrooms and peppers to mine!!! Clean plates all around!! Thank you!!!

    Reply

  24. Emmy -

    Just wanted to let you know that I found this recipe on Pinterest and it’s now one of my favorites! This was SO easy to make and really filling, too. Thanks!

    Reply

  25. Megan and Emily @WhimsicallyHomemade -

    Hey there! Just wanted to let you know we featured you in our Favorite Find Fridays post over at Whimsically Homemade. We used one of your pictures. If that’s a problem let us know and we’ll remove it immediately. Thanks for your great inspiration!

    Reply

  26. Mindy -

    We made this tonight and my two boys loved it. My husband wasn’t too excited until he tasted it and said it was awesome! Thanks for the idea!

    Reply

  27. Christine -

    I so got to make this for my boyfriend! Can I put the ingredients on half of the tortilla and then fold it over though?

    Reply

  28. Keeley -

    I used turkey pepperoni, and it turned out AMAZING! We had it 2 days in a row, and its alittle more of a “skinnier” version :)

    Reply

  29. Lynnette -

    These are awesome! We have made them several times now experimenting with different ingredients. They have quickly became a family favorite. We not only do pizza toppings, but other things as well. Recently we used a little A1, steak, pepperjack cheese.YUMMY! So many variations make this an all around win =) Thanks for sharing! I found on Pinterest and repinned for others!

    Reply

  31. Teri -

    Any suggestions on how to make ahead and freeze? These wold be great for the kids to be able to come home from school and just heat up.

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      Although I’ve never tried it, I bet you could freeze them right after putting them together (before cooking them). Then the kids could just put them in a pan to heat them up. OR, if you only want them using the microwave, I’d recommend freezing after you cook them, to get the crispy exterior.

      Reply

  32. Andrea -

    Pizza and quesadillas? Yummy!!!!! Great idea, I’m going to try them soon :-)
    BTW, I had no problem printing the recipe.

    Reply

  33. Kaci -

    I made these tonight, with the help of my son! Fun recipe to include the little ones. He enjoyed making his own! We added banana peppers to ours and pineapple to my 4 year olds! They were delicious! We will definitely make these again!

    Reply

  34. Katie -

    I made these tonight with corn tortillas, because it was all I had, and they weren’t that great. The corn flavor really overpowered everything else. I wouldn’t recommend using them unless you have to. I’ll definitely try again with flour!

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      Good to know. I was skeptical that corn tortillas would taste good – they’re really overpowering and probably wouldn’t meld well with Italian food. Thanks for sharing! Definitely try with flour:)

      Reply

  36. Ruth Calahan -

    This are two of my grandson’s favorite foods. He loves the Pepperoni Pizza /chicken Quesadillas, combination. Totally awesome!

    Reply

  37. Angie -

    I made these using homemade sourdough wheat tortilla’s (lower carbs). And oh my, but were they good. And thanks for posting the recipe calculator, I make a lot of things from scratch.

    Reply

  38. Marci -

    Just found this on Pinterest! We have a quesadilla maker & use it all the time-can’t believe I haven’t thought of this before!! Can’t wait to make them this week!

    Reply

  40. Amanda -

    Love this! I saw it on Pinterest and re-posted it in Stuffdot. We LOVE pizza in our house so I seriously can’t believe we’ve never thought of this. Awesome post and and I can’t wait to make it this weekend.

    Reply

  41. Nicole -

    Hello I love the idea of Pepperoni Pizza Quesadilla. I love combination of the 2 worlds.I love pizza and quesadillas. What a great party appetizer I think I will try this when I am invited to a party.Thank you for sharing your talents.By the please checkout my website its :www.simplybittenkitchen.net I think you’d like it.
    Have a good holiday season.

    Reply

  43. Leslie -

    I just made these for supper, my 2 very picky boys loved them. They were so easy, literally like 5 minutes and they were done. Will be making these again

    Reply

  45. Brittany -

    So i was wondering, is there a way to bake them to server multiples for larger groups or a party? i am making these for a semi small get together and feel that if i do this stove top, the first few ones will be cold by the time im finished.. any suggestions?

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      I would recommend doing them on the stove top like usual, but then putting them on a baking sheet in a 200 degree oven to keep them warm while you cook the rest. Goodluck!

      Reply

  46. MaMa's cookin -

    I was looking for easy things to fix for a job sight lunch for my son and other workers. This is going on my menu. Thanks!

    Reply

    • Sarah Menanix -

      Thanks for your question, Karen! Since the specific ingredients used in each recipe can vary extensively from one person to the next, I don’t provide the nutritional information. However, you can plug the exact ingredients you use into a free online calorie counters – this is my favorite one to use. Happy cooking!

      Reply

  48. leslie -

    This sounds so delicious I will make this today
    I’m not every much of a cooker but lately I’ve been cooking up stuff that I know I can make slowly I’m moving forward into make difficult dishes
    Thank god for Pinterest!

    Reply

  49. Jasmine -

    Yummy! This has become one of my weeknight favs. Quick and easy, especially after a long day. I don’t fry the pepperoni before. I used marinara sauce instead of pizza. I spread the sauce on the tortilla, sprinkle cheese, then pepperonis. Folded over and placed on griddle. I like mine to be browned and crispy. Thanks for the recipe!

    Reply

  51. Realtimedairy -

    My love for the kitchen is slowly pushing me away from the cows and its such recipes that make me so happu when i hit the kitchen. I’ll be trying this recipe hoping my boys will love it. To them, im the best cook and its people like you who give me that pride. Thanks

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *